MemberSpace vs Memberstack (2026): which should you pick?

Pick MemberSpace if

• Fits if you have a site on Squarespace, Wix or Webflow and want a members area on it
• Works for a creator selling one or two paid tiers

Look elsewhere if

• Pricey if you have steady sales: Starter takes 5% of every sale
• Tight if you want an API or the AI connection, which are on the $99 Growth plan
• Watch out: Starter allows one website connection
• Watch out: the site builder is a separate cost, since it runs on top of another site

Pick Memberstack if

• Fits if you build on Webflow and want logins and gated pages
• Works for a small paid community under 1,000 members

Look elsewhere if

• Pricey if you sell a lot: 4%, 2% or 0.9% transaction fees apply on lower tiers on top of Stripe's
• Tight if you grow: Basic stops at 1,000 members
• Skip it if you are not on Webflow or Stripe, as the page is framed around them
• Watch out: the $399 Established plan is the way to remove the fee entirely

MemberSpace

• The Starter plan takes a 5% fee on every sale and allows one website connection.
• API access and the AI connection are on the $99 Growth plan only.
• The pricing page shows annual rates; a monthly option is offered but its price was not shown in the page text.
• It runs on top of another site, so the site builder is a separate cost.

Memberstack

• The pricing page frames the product around Webflow sites and Stripe payments.
• Transaction fees of 4%, 2% or 0.9% apply on lower tiers, on top of Stripe's fees.
• Tiers are set by member count, with the cheapest plan stopping at 1,000 members.

MemberSpace

Membership on any site

Installs on an existing site and locks pages, files or videos behind a member login.

Free and paid tiers

Sells one-time, payment-plan and recurring access, with free trials of any length.

Spaces for members

Offers community forums, content libraries, courses, newsletters, coaching areas and directories to members.

Member migration

Imports members from another platform at no charge.

Analytics and automations

Reports revenue and activity and sends automatic emails.

Admin API and AI connection

Growth adds API access and a way to connect a ChatGPT or Claude account to analyze member data.

Memberstack

Member logins

Email, social, passwordless and custom SSO sign-in, listed on every plan.

Stripe payments

Subscriptions, one-time payments and trials through Stripe, with the processing fee paid on top of the plan.

Content gating

Make pages members-only without writing code, based on a member's plan or role.

Member data

Profiles, roles and custom fields stored per member, working as a lightweight member CRM.

Branded email

Branded transactional emails and email campaigns are listed on every plan.

Same features, falling fee

The vendor says every tier has the same features; the transaction fee drops as the tier rises.

MemberSpace

• Starter$39

  per month, billed annually

  5% MemberSpace fee on each sale on top of Stripe's fees; unlimited members and tiers, 5 member spaces, 1 website connection.

• Growth$99

  per month, billed annually

  2% fee on each sale; unlimited spaces, 3 website connections, admin API access and ChatGPT or Claude connection.

Memberstack

• Basic$25

  per month for up to 1,000 members, billed yearly ($29 billed monthly)

  4% transaction fee plus standard Stripe fees.

• Professional$39

  per month for up to 5,000 members, billed yearly ($49 billed monthly)

  2% transaction fee plus standard Stripe fees.

• Business$79

  per month for 10,000+ members, billed yearly ($99 billed monthly)

  0.9% transaction fee plus standard Stripe fees.

• Established$399

  per month for 10,000+ members, billed yearly ($499 billed monthly)

  No transaction fee, only standard Stripe processing fees.

MemberSpace

No public discounts listed.

Memberstack

• Annual discount

  Save 20% with yearly billing

  The pricing page shows each plan about 20% cheaper when billed yearly, for example $79 against $99 a month on Business.