AppearOnAI vs Goodie (2026): which should you pick?

Pick AppearOnAI if

• Fits if you want a one-off audit and a 30-day plan without a subscription
• Works for agencies reselling white-label reports, on the sales-led Agency plan

Look elsewhere if

• Pricey if you want ongoing tracking, at $249 a month for weekly updates
• Skip it if you need real-time tracking, an API or white-label reports, which are on sales-led plans
• Not for you if you want clear Enterprise pricing: one page says $500 a month, another says custom
• Watch out: the engines named vary by page, so confirm which ones you'd get
• Not for you if you want a trial: there's one free analysis, then the $99 audit

Pick Goodie if

• Fits if you want the tracking and the content work that follows it in one tool, at $295 a month or more
• Works for teams selling products who need SKU-level AI shopping data, which starts on Pro at $999

Look elsewhere if

• Pricey if you just want to know whether ChatGPT mentions you, at $295 a month even on yearly billing
• Tight if you run several brands, as Core covers one brand, two countries and 5 of its 13 engines
• Skip it if you need the API or multi-brand reporting, which only come with Enterprise
• Watch out: Pro jumps to $999 a month, is started through a demo, and is where Slack support begins
• Watch out: agents run on 50 optimization actions a month on Core, and monthly billing adds $59 to Core's price

AppearOnAI

• Its pages disagree: a plain version of the pricing page lists Enterprise at $500 a month, while the live page shows it as custom-priced.
• Ongoing tracking starts at $249 a month and refreshes weekly; real-time tracking is Enterprise only.
• The engines named vary by page: ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Perplexity everywhere, plus Grok, Copilot and Meta AI on some.
• Yearly billing is offered at 20% off, but the yearly price was not shown in the page text read.

Goodie

• The entry price is higher than many trackers: Core is $295 a month on annual billing for 110 prompts and one brand.
• Core tracks 5 core models; the vendor lists 13 engines in all, and up to 14 models only on Enterprise.
• Core and Pro list MCP access; API access and centralized multi-brand reporting appear only in the Enterprise plan.
• Core support is by email only; Slack support starts on Pro.

AppearOnAI

AI Visibility Score

A 0 to 100 score of how often AI platforms recognize and recommend your site, with citation coverage and query reach.

Recommendations and roadmap

Personalized fixes for your business, 10 in the audit and 40 on Growth, with a 30-day implementation roadmap.

Competitor and sentiment analysis

Side-by-side visibility against competitors and whether AI describes your brand positively or negatively.

Prompt tracking

Growth queries AI platforms weekly with 100 target prompts and tracks mentions, rankings and the sources AI cites.

AutoBlogger

Writes blog posts aimed at being cited by AI assistants, alongside a blog optimizer, on Growth and above.

Goodie

Visibility monitoring

Daily tracking of mentions, citations, sentiment and competitor share across AI engines, with country and historical trend views.

Brand Command

Checks what AI answers claim about a brand against the facts and messaging pillars you set, and reports inaccuracy and adverse citation rates.

Agents and optimization actions

Content writer, blog, outreach, social and technical agents (llms.txt and sitemap repair) work through a monthly allowance of action credits.

Agentic commerce tracking

Pro and above track how products appear in AI shopping answers, at SKU level, including AI Mode and Walmart's Sparky.

Agent analytics and attribution

Logs AI crawler visits and AI-referred traffic through Google Analytics, Search Console, Bing Webmaster Tools, Vercel, Cloudflare and CloudFront.

Prompt research

Finds prompts customers ask AI in a category, with volume patterns and trending topics; 30 a month on Core and 80 on Pro.

AppearOnAI

• One-Time Audit$99

  one-time

  A visibility score, 10 recommendations, competitor and sentiment analysis, a 30-day roadmap and a PDF export.

• Growth$249

  per month for 100 target prompts, refreshed weekly

  10+ AI models, 40 recommendations, citation and source tracking, the blog optimizer and AutoBlogger, and priority support.

• EnterpriseCustom

  Real-time tracking, unlimited queries, backlink and keyword data, API access, white-label reports and an SLA. Sold after a demo.

• AgencyCustom

  Unlimited client brands, white-label reports, a client dashboard, API access and revenue-sharing options.

Goodie

• Core$295

  per month for 110 prompts, billed annually ($354 monthly)

  5 core AI models, 1 brand, 2 countries, daily data, MCP access, 50 optimization actions a month, unlimited seats and email support.

• Pro$999

  per month for 250 prompts, billed annually ($1,198.80 monthly)

  8 models, 5 countries, 100 actions a month, product-level AI shopping visibility, email and Slack support. Started through a demo.

• EnterpriseCustom

  Up to 14 models, 500+ prompts, 8+ countries, multi-brand reporting, full revenue attribution, API access and a dedicated AEO strategist.

AppearOnAI

• Annual discount

  Save 20% with yearly billing

  The pricing page's billing switch says paying yearly saves 20% compared with paying monthly.

Goodie

• Annual discount

  Two months free with annual billing

  Goodie's pricing page offers 2 months free on annual billing: Core is $295 a month billed annually against $354 billed monthly.